Choosing a Smart Home Brand: Shelly, SwitchBot, Govee, Reolink & Aqara Compared

Choosing a Smart Home Brand: Shelly, SwitchBot, Govee, Reolink & Aqara Compared

The smart home market is crowded, but these five brands all have very different sweet spots. Shelly, SwitchBot, Govee, Reolink and Aqara are not really competing hubs in the way Alexa and Google Home are – they are ecosystems that each excel at particular jobs: deep retrofits, no-tools upgrades, ambience, security, or whole-home automation.

This guide explains what each ecosystem is good at in real life, and the kinds of scenarios where they actually make sense.

Shelly – Power-User Control and Pro-Grade Retrofits

What Shelly Is About

Shelly focuses on Wi-Fi–connected relays, switches and sensors that sit behind existing fittings and give you granular control over power circuits. Their compact relays are designed to fit behind standard wall switches and sockets and turn almost anything – lights, fans, pumps, garage doors – into a smart device you can automate.

That means you don't have to replace your light fittings or sockets with "smart" ones; you keep the look of your décor and just smarten the wiring behind it. Shelly devices typically:

  • Connect directly over Wi-Fi, with some newer devices also supporting Zigbee
  • Offer local control via web interfaces, MQTT, REST and scripting
  • Integrate with Alexa, Google Assistant and many third-party platforms

Who Shelly Suits Best

  • Renovators and homeowners comfortable with electrics
    Ideal if you (or your electrician) are happy working inside back boxes and consumer units and want to smarten an entire property without changing visible hardware.
  • Tinkerers and integrators
    MQTT, webhooks and scripting make Shelly friendly to Home Assistant and other DIY platforms. It's great if you want automations that go beyond most "consumer" apps.
  • Small businesses
    Useful for controlling lighting, signage, HVAC contactors and other loads in shops, cafés, offices and warehouses while keeping existing wiring and fittings.

Typical Shelly Scenarios

  • Whole-home lighting automation using existing switches
  • Irrigation, pumps or underfloor heating on smart schedules
  • Energy-saving automations tied to occupancy, tariff or solar production

SwitchBot – Smart Home Without Touching the Wiring

What SwitchBot Is About

SwitchBot's core idea is simple: instead of rewiring, physically press the buttons you already have. The SwitchBot Bot sticks next to a rocker switch or appliance button and presses it for you; the ecosystem then expands into smart curtains, blind motors, meters, plugs, locks and hubs.

The result is a smart home ecosystem built for renters and non-DIYers:

  • Most devices install with adhesive or brackets, not tools
  • You can automate legacy kit such as boilers, coffee machines and dumb switches
  • Hubs add remote control, voice assistant support and, on newer models, Matter support

Who SwitchBot Suits Best

  • Renters and people who can't modify wiring
    If your landlord doesn't want you touching the electrics, SwitchBot lets you automate without changing anything permanent.
  • Quick-win upgrades
    Perfect for scheduling a coffee machine, automating curtains or controlling a fan from your phone.
  • Offices and shared spaces
    You can automate lighting or equipment without reworking the electrical system, ideal for small offices or temporary setups.

Typical SwitchBot Scenarios

  • Sticking bots on boiler controls, intercoms or hallway lights
  • Motorising existing curtains instead of replacing the rail or track
  • Using a hub to tie dumb appliances into Alexa, Google or Apple via Matter

Govee – Immersive Lighting and Visual Ambience

What Govee Is About

Govee has built its name on colourful, highly configurable smart lighting – LED strips, light bars, screen-sync systems and outdoor lights designed to transform rooms into immersive spaces. The focus is on ambient lighting for living rooms, gaming setups and outdoor areas, with an emphasis on effects and value rather than heavy "infrastructure" automation.

Govee's ecosystem stands out for:

  • A strong app with advanced scenes, music-reactive modes and DIY effects
  • Screen-sync products for TVs and monitors to enhance films and games
  • Growing support for Matter and major voice assistants on newer models

Who Govee Suits Best

  • Gamers and content creators
    Ideal if your priority is a dramatic gaming cave or highly branded streaming background.
  • Home cinema and living rooms
    Great for bias lighting behind TVs, wall-washing effects and synced light bars when picture and mood matter most.
  • Budget-conscious ambience
    Delivers big visual impact for less money than many design-led lighting brands.

Typical Govee Scenarios

  • RGBIC strips and light bars synced to movies or games
  • Bedroom or studio setups with layered colours and scenes
  • Outdoor entertaining spaces with scheduled or trigger-based lighting

Reolink – Focused, No-Nonsense Smart Security

What Reolink Is About

Reolink focuses on video security: Wi-Fi and PoE IP cameras, NVR kits, floodlight cams and accessories. Their NVR (Network Video Recorder) systems are designed for simple setup, 24/7 recording and multi-camera coverage for homes and businesses.

Key characteristics include:

  • A wide choice of 4K, PTZ, dual-lens and floodlight cameras
  • Options for purely local recording to NVRs or microSD – no forced subscription
  • A mix of Wi-Fi and PoE models to cover a range of property sizes and layouts
  • Apps and desktop clients focused on live view, playback and alerting

Who Reolink Suits Best

  • Homeowners with serious security needs
    Ideal if you want full-coverage CCTV rather than just a video doorbell.
  • Small businesses and sites
    Well suited to forecourts, car parks, workshops and offices that need multi-camera systems.
  • Privacy-conscious users
    Local recording means you're not locked into a specific cloud subscription if you don't want it.

Typical Reolink Scenarios

  • Perimeter coverage around a detached house using a mix of fixed and PTZ cameras
  • Multi-camera coverage of a yard, warehouse or office estate
  • Floodlight cameras covering blind spots in gardens or driveways

Aqara – Hub-Based Whole-Home Automation on a Budget

What Aqara Is About

Aqara is a hub-based smart home ecosystem built around Zigbee and, more recently, Thread and Matter. An Aqara hub acts as the brain, connecting to your network and managing a large number of child devices such as sensors, switches, curtain motors and locks.

The brand's strengths are:

  • A wide range of compact sensors (motion, contact, water leak, vibration, presence, environmental)
  • Attractive, minimalist switches, wall controls and curtain/blind motors
  • Deep integrations with Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa, SmartThings and Matter-capable platforms
  • Strong security and alarm-style features such as arming modes, notifications and sirens

Who Aqara Suits Best

  • People who want whole-home automation without overspending
    You can cover a house with sensors and switches for less than many premium ecosystems.
  • Apple Home users and Matter adopters
    Aqara hubs and newer devices work well as a sensor and control layer feeding into your preferred controller.
  • Both homeowners and renters
    Battery-powered sensors and plug-in hubs mean you can deploy a lot without drilling, while hard-wired switches suit larger renovations.

Typical Aqara Scenarios

  • Smart security using door/window contacts, motion sensors and sirens
  • Presence-based lighting and heating control using motion and presence sensors
  • Automated blinds, window treatments and scene buttons around the home

How to Choose – and When to Mix Ecosystems

You don't have to marry one brand forever. In reality, most smart homes end up with a mix:

  • Infrastructure & retrofits: Shelly (and sometimes Aqara switches)
  • No-tools add-ons: SwitchBot
  • Ambience: Govee
  • Security: Reolink
  • Sensors & "brain": Aqara (or Shelly feeding into your own controller)

A sensible way to approach it:

  1. Decide your primary job to be done.
    "I want the house to feel modern and convenient" → Aqara plus some SwitchBot.
    "I want full CCTV coverage" → Reolink.
    "I want lighting that really stands out" → Govee.
    "I want total control over every circuit" → Shelly.
  2. Check what smart platform you already use.
    If you're deep into Apple Home, focus on Aqara/Thread/Matter-friendly options. If you're on Alexa or Google Home, all five can feed in, but always check specific model compatibility.
  3. Be honest about your appetite for wiring and configuration.
    If you're not going near a consumer unit, Shelly becomes an electrician's job, while SwitchBot and Aqara's battery devices may be a better fit.

For most people, a future-proof setup looks like this: a standards-based hub or controller (Apple Home, Google Home, SmartThings, Home Assistant or Matter), Aqara and Shelly for sensors and switching, Govee for "wow" lighting, SwitchBot for awkward legacy devices, and Reolink for serious video security. That gives you flexibility without being locked into a single vendor's vision.

Back to blog